You are viewing our old site. See the new one here

go to IISDnet
8th Meeting of the Commission on Sustainable Development
New York, USA; 24 April - 05 May, 2000
 

CSD-8 Side-Events for Thursday 04 May


FAO Screening : "Sustainable Agriculture and Rural Development : Challenges and Opportunities"

The new video produced by Antonello Proto at the FAO Information Division addressed the socio-economic factors underlying the need to promote and implement Sustainable Agriculture and Rural Development (SARD). Global inequality refers to the 1/3 of the world's population living on less than $1 per day, the 800 million people who don't have access to enough food, and hunger/malnutrition being a serious concern in many countries. These population pressures and demands on agriculture will continue to grow, and farmers who lack adequate access to technology and face diminishing returns, will need to find new ways to survive. Poverty brings land-degradation, and land-degradation brings poverty, intensification of land-use, sterile land, soil erosion, and desertification.  This self-perpetuating cycle can be curbed by rational land-practices and rural development.

Achieving sustainable agriculture leads to rural development, and this process involves combining appropriate technologies with innovative thinking based on local knowledge with a view to maintaining land fertility and rational resource use. The film is a good introduction to these issues, and overviews case studies in integrated land management, rural community development through popular education on farming, diversified agriculture, conservation farming, the use of seed hybrids to increase yields. But yields are only one part of the picture, working alongside conservation of natural resources and providing some increases in living standards for farmers. Although increasing land production can lead to increased incomes, they can also drive down prices for the consumer, and depress local economies over time.


From Rio to CSD-8 and Beyond : Roundtable discussion on progress made and the multi-stakeholder dialogue preparation for 2002.

Organized by IPSA, the International Agri-Food Network and ICFTU, this panel first described the events that led to sustainable agriculture to the decision-making forum at CSD-8.  General overviews of salient issues arising from the CSD-8 multi-stakeholder dialogue were presented, and thoughts about the future of sustainable agriculture were discussed, including the proposal for the establishment of a Working Group.

 
Photo (left to right) Gordon Nesbitt, International Confederation of Free Trade Unions (ICFTU); Gordon Bispham, Caribbean Policy Development Centre, Co-Chair CSD-8 NGO Caucus; Chair Linda Elswick, Sustainable Agriculture/Food Systems (SAFS), Co-Chair CSD-8 NGO Caucus; Thomas Forster, International Partners for Sustainable Agriculture (IPSA) ; and Annik Dollacker, International Agri-Food Network.
 
 
Thomas Forster, (IPSA), opened the discussion with an overview of last week's CSD-8 Multi-Stakeholder Dialogue addressing 4 main areas of concern : choices in production techniques and consumption patterns; best practices in land resource management; knowledge for sustainable food systems including knowledge sharing; and macro-economic conditions for sustainable agriculture (re: trade liberalization and globalization). The point that all parties agreed upon was that in order for SARD to be achievable, civil society had to be actively engaged, knowledgeable about the issues, and involved in the decision-making process.

There were also 2 schools of thought regarding what Forster described as "shallow-" and "deep-SARD". Shallow SARD referred to a focus on production techniques, quantitative targets and measures to close the world's hunger/malnutrition gap. Deep SARD refers to a fundamental paradigm shift away from the industrialized food system as a way to feed the world, to the support of diversified, small-holder food producers made up of individual farmers and farmer networks.


Photo : Thomas Forster, International 
Partners for Sustainable Agriculture (IPSA).

Within the last 9 years since UNCED, civil society's knowledge about agri-food issues have hit a high point, with large public awareness of GMOs and biotechnological potentials. This calls for more research attention, more public policy development, and more industry and marketing responsibility – a broad systemic understanding about the agri-food industry, which is what SARD is really trying to achieve.

Gordon Bispham, of the Caribbean Policy Development Centre, and CSD-8 NGO Caucus Co-Chair, noted that UNCED brought thousands of farms together to discuss Chapter 14 on sustainable agriculture. Organic and ecologically friendly agriculture is outgrowing industrial agriculture in Europe. Biotechnology (especially GMOs) came front and centre on the negotiating table as a signal that we need to move away from heavy dependence on chemicals, fertilizers, and genetic engineering, because in the case of GMOs, evidence is not conclusive and the precautionary principle should be exercised in the interests of human health and ecological integrity. At the same time, its important to realize that the environmental debate of the early 1990's is only starting to gain a strong foothold in many countries, despite the advanced negotiations that we are now engaging in. Nevertheless, the foundation for cooperation has been laid. The establishment of a Working Group would provide a forum to flesh out details to bring to the negotiating table.
Annik Dollacker of the International Agri-Food Network, noted that its more favourable to increase productivity on existing agricultural lands than to expand to cultivate new and fragile ecosystems. Industry produces technologies that can contribute to this goal, and in the past 20 years has changed rapidly in response to problems encountered in the field. Its important to view the whole system of research and development as a process of learning and improvement, and that there is not one singular solution to the problems, but a balance to be struck among economic, socio-cultural and environmental sectors.

We are interested in continuing this dialogue through the establishment of a Working Group to bring our interests to the table. Rio+10 will be a good forum for collaboration, and a place where all sectors can meet to implement new strategies on the ground. Industry has always been a key player in developing solutions to implement on the ground, and there are links that can be built upon here at CSD-8.


Briefing by the Co-Chairs of the Ad Hoc Open-ended Intergovernmental Group of Experts on Energy and Sustainable Development on the outcome of the 1st session of the Group of Experts held in New York from 06-10 March 2000.


Photo (left to right) : Co-Chairs, Mohammed Reza Salamat, (Iran) and Irene Freudenschuss Reichl,  (Austria).


ENB Summary of Ad Hoc Open-Ended Intergovernmental Group of Experts on Energy and Sustainable Development
CSD-8 Intersessionals
Linkages CSD page
UN - CSD website with official documents 
ENB's "Introduction to CSD"

click to top 

© 2000, Earth Negotiations Bulletin. All rights reserved.