EARTH NEGOTIATIONS BULLETIN PUBLISHED BY THE INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT (IISD) WRITTEN AND EDITED BY: JOHANNAH BERNSTEIN LANGSTON JAMES GOREE VI "KIMO" LYNN WAGNER STEVE WISE French translation by MONGI GADHOUM < gad@Tunisia.EU.net> A DAILY REPORT ON THE WORLD SUMMIT FOR SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT Vol. 10 No. 42 11 March 1995 WORLD SUMMIT FOR SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT HIGHLIGHTS FRIDAY, 10 MARCH 1995 MAIN COMMITTEE - AFTERNOON The Main Committee heard comments from NGO delegates and heads of UN agencies during an afternoon session. Bella Abzug (Womens' Environment and Development Organization) said that the Women's Caucus and NGOs will ensure that governments read and implement the Summit Declaration. Dirk Jarre (International Council on Social Welfare) stated that the new language articulated by the Summit may lead to a new culture of shared resources, opportunities, power and responsibilities. Fatoumata Sire Diakite (African Caucus) called for upgrading African expertise and technologies and attention to the cultural dimension of development. Roberto Bissio (Development Caucus) stated that the poor do not want help, they want work. Max van den Berg (NOVIB) noted that social elements of development are on the international agenda and called for greater governmental accountability. Pauline Cantwell (Peace Caucus) stressed the need to clear land mines and halt their production and sale. Kandeh Yilla (International Organization of Free Trade Unions) stated that trade unions on all continents will ask their governments to translate the Summit into tangible results, including resource commitments. Jan Birket-Smith (organizer of the NGO Forum) stated that movements toward selfishness, xenophobia, racism and fear will be substituted with freedom of the individual and the family and by solidarity between people. Peggy Antrobus (DAWN) said that the realization of a new vision of development requires the transformation of gender relations. Lalita Balakrisnan (Forum for Energy and Development) noted the need to integrate environmental and social development and encouraged technology transfer that includes knowledge transfer and the use of indigenous knowledge. Ellis Envall (International Federation of Social Workers) called for national strategies to contain specific targets related to food, health, social services, family rights and employment. James Gustave Speth (UNDP Administrator) stated that UNDP can deliver a country-driven response in those countries in which it works, and promised to support implementation as a primary objective. Francisco Vio Grossi (Peoples' Alliance for Social Development) expressed concern that the root causes of social problems are not dealt with in the Summit documents. Federico Mayor (UNESCO Secretary-General) said that UNESCO, in cooperation with WHO, other partners of the UN system, and NGOs, will promote activities to achieve social justice and to counter social exclusion. Nafis Sadik (UNFPA Executive-Director) stated that Commitment 6 gives attention to gender disparity, one of the principle focuses of the Cairo Programme of Action. Carol Lubin (International Federation of Settlements and Neighborhood Centers) said that NGOs should have more specific roles in follow-up, as contractors with specialized agencies. Richard Jolly (UNICEF Acting Executive-Director) stressed: the importance of national strategies for development; the need to build alliances for implementation; and the importance of serious follow-up and monitoring. Ibrahim Samba (WHO Regional Director for Africa) said that he took seriously the challenge of NGOs to plan together with UN agencies to alleviate the plight of the unfortunate. Carlos Fortin (UNCTAD Secretary-General) noted that, according to UNCTAD's findings, the extent to which the process of international trade liberalization will reduce poverty in the Third World will not be even .5 percent. To close the afternoon session, Amb. Somavi'a lead delegates in a minute of silence in honor of the late Jim Grant, whose vision made the Summit possible. MAIN COMMITTEE - EVENING The Main Committee re-convened at 7:30 pm to adopt the final texts that had been agreed in the Butler and Razali contact groups. The Butler group had agreed to a new paragraph 28, which states that implementation of social development is the responsibility of each country and should take into account the economic, social and environmental diversity, as well as religious and ethical values of each country. Secondly, new language was agreed on Commitment 9(d), which now refers to refraining from unilateral measures "not in accordance with international law and the Charter of the United Nations that create obstacles to trade relations among States." And finally, new language was agreed for the chapeau to paragraphs 17 and sub-paragraph 17(a). They were combined into one paragraph, which states that international support for national efforts to promote a favourable political and legal environment must be in conformity with the UN Charter, principles of international law and the Declaration on Principles of International Law concerning Friendly Relations. These new paragraphs were adopted by the Main Committee. Amb. Razali noted that efforts were made to remove the brackets around sub-paragraph 90(g) (debt relief for middle- income countries). Agreement was also reached on a new paragraph 6 (interdependence of social and economic development). This paragraph states, in part, that "broad- based and sustained economic growth in the context of sustainable development is necessary to sustain social development and social justice." The G-77 expressed dissatisfaction with the text but agreed to it in the spirit of cooperation. After the Main Committee formally adopted the draft Declaration and the Programme of Action, Somavi'a opened the floor for delegates to express their reservations to the texts. Iraq reserved on Commitment 9(d), stating that the text as proposed was completely different from the text in the Declaration and was incompatible with the essence of the original Commitment 9. Tunisia removed its reservation on Commitment 9(d). Guatemala reserved on the references to "territorial integrity" in the Declaration, noting its current territorial disputes. Belize registered its protest against Guatemala's comments. Costa Rica reserved with respect to paragraph 21 (reduction of military expenditures). Iraq expressed concern that the social consequences of trade sanctions were not sufficiently reflected in the text. Ecuador, Argentina, the Holy See, the Sudan and Malta reserved on reproductive health. The floor was then opened for general comments. Amb. Butler (Australia) highlighted the important commitment that governments have made to attack poverty as well as the new relationship between institutions, governments and civil society. The US highlighted the importance of the Commitment on the eradication of poverty, the language on SAPs, the empowerment of women, workers' rights, and the integration of disabled citizens and other marginalized groups. The Netherlands suggested that poverty and social exclusion issues should have been addressed in northern countries. Canada said that the Declaration and Programme of Action form a set of international norms and values that link social development with economic development through the principle of sustainable development. The Russian Federation said that the Programme of Action would aid his government as a basis for domestic social policy. Nitin Desai, Under- Secretary-General for Policy Coordination and Sustainable Development, said that the Summit brought together two strands within the UN, one that gives expression to the realities of interdependencies and the other that reflects the shared vision of a just society. REVIEW OF DRAFT DECLARATION AND PROGRAMME OF ACTION The following is a description of some of the agreements that were reached here on those issues that were deferred by PrepCom III. DECLARATION: In paragraph 27 (social situation in countries with economies in transition), delegates added text on the economic and social deterioration in countries with economies in transition. In Commitment 1(i) (new and additional financial resources), the reference to "such resources must be both adequate and predictable" was replaced with a reference to maximizing the availability of such resources. Commitment 3(i) (ensuring quality jobs) now stresses respect for relevant ILO Conventions. Commitment 6(c) (solutions to external debt problems) calls for immediate implementation of the terms of debt forgiveness agreed in the Paris Club. NEW COMMITMENT ON EDUCATION AND HEALTH: The final text strengthened the language on health from "basic health services" to "the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health." The preamble's text on culture was also expanded. The national level commitments add emphasis to gender issues and the priority of women and girls in several paragraphs. Other paragraphs new to the national commitments were: (g) (indigenous people); (i) (links between labour market and education policies); (k) (learning acquisition and outcome); (p) (maternal and child health objectives); (q) (HIV/AIDS education); and (r) (environmental awareness). The international level commitments section include: (v) (intergovernmental organizations); (w) (UN support for combatting major diseases); (x) (technology transfer); and (y) (international support for women and children). CHAPTER I. AN ENABLING ENVIRONMENT FOR SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT: Paragraph 10(a) (debt) calls for efforts to alleviate the debt burden. Paragraph 11(e) (solutions to external debt) calls for effective, development-oriented and durable solutions. Paragraph 11(h) qualifies the commitment to increased ODA as "consistent with countries' economic circumstances and capacity to assist...as soon as possible." Paragraph 15(c) (right to development) weakened the original language, calling for governments to only "take measures to ensure" development. CHAPTER II. ERADICATION OF POVERTY: The revised text in paragraph 25 (bullet 9) (policies that sustain family stability) calls for policies in accordance with the Social Summit Declaration and the ICPD. In paragraph 37(d) (access for people living in poverty to primary health care services), delegates deleted the reference to access to "preventive health care," but they called for primary health care "free of charge or at affordable rates." In paragraph 37(e) (reproductive health care), delegates called for national strategies for "improving reproductive health care and child health care services," and specified services to be provided consistent with the ICPD. In paragraph 38(i) (social safety net), delegates agreed to "ensure" a social safety net under SAPs. CHAPTER III. THE EXPANSION OF PRODUCTIVE EMPLOYMENT AND THE REDUCTION OF UNEMPLOYMENT: In paragraphs 46 (unremunerated work) and 64(b) (developing knowledge of work), references to unremunerated work as part of national accounting systems were replaced with references to developing methods for reflecting its value in quantitative terms for possible reflection separate from national accounts. In 54(b) (basic workers' rights), delegates called for the full implementation of ILO conventions for parties to the conventions or taking them into account for States that are not party. CHAPTER IV. SOCIAL INTEGRATION: Paragraph 71 (bullet 12) (dangers of armed conflict) now acknowledges "legitimate national defence needs" before the call for reducing excessive military expenditures. In paragraph 75(f) (structural adjustment programmes), delegates agreed to "ensure" that SAPs are designed to minimize their negative impacts. A new section G (Social integration and family responsibilities) calls for: support for the family; opportunities for family members to understand their social responsibilities; mutual respect within the family; and equal partnership between women and men in the family. CHAPTER V. IMPLEMENTATION AND FOLLOW-UP: In paragraph 82 (bullet 6) (mobilize funding sources), the reference to "available" funding sources was replaced with a call for "adequate and predictable and mobilized in a way that maximizes the availability of such resources." In paragraph 83(d) (20:20) delegates agreed that "interested developed and developing partners" could allocate twenty percent of ODA and twenty percent of the national budget, respectively, to basic social programmes. Paragraphs 90(b) (bilateral debt of Africa and LDCs) and 90(c) (debt of other developing countries) were replaced with a call to reduce the bilateral debt of the LDCs and to explore innovative approaches to debt relief for other developing countries. In paragraph 95(e) (ECOSOC to oversee UN coordination of implementation), delegates deleted the call for ECOSOC to recommend ways to improve UN capacity to analyse and respond to economic and social crisis. In paragraph 95(f) (ECOSOC oversight method), ECOSOC, "within the framework of the discussions on an Agenda for Development," should consider holding joint meetings with the Development Committee of the World Bank and IMF. THINGS TO LOOK FOR TODAY PLENARY: The Summit segment of the WSSD will convene today at 9:30 am to hear statements from 45 heads of State or Government. The opening statement will be made by Danish Minister Poul Nyrup Rasmussen. UN Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Ghali will give the second statement. LEADERS IN CYBERSPACE: The UN exhibit "Summitry Works" has moved into the Bella Center. The display features a link into the Internet, where it is hoped that world leaders will respond "on-line" to some of more than 2200 e-mail messages sent to them by youth from 69 countries in the "Voices of Youth" project. This exhibit joins the 400 works of children's art entitled, "Our Point of View: Youth and the Social Summit" that forms at 68 meter-long wall in Bella Center. This issue of the Earth Negotiations Bulletin (C) is written and edited by Johannah Bernstein, Langston James Goree VI "Kimo" , Lynn Wagner and Steve Wise with French translation by Mongi Gadhoum . The Sustaining Donors of the Bulletin are the International Institute for Sustainable Development (iisd@web.apc.org), the United Nations Environment Programme and the Pew Charitable Trusts. General support for the Bulletin during 1995 is provided by the United Kingdom, Denmark, Switzerland and the World Bank. Funding for the Bulletin at the Social Summit has been provided by UNDP and UNICEF and ACCT. Special thanks to macKeenzie Copy Center for photocopying services and Dknet for our Internet feed. The authors can be contacted at their electronic mail addresses and by cellular phone during this meeting at +45 401 38818 or 331 47797. The opinions expressed in Earth Negotiations Bulletin are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of IISD and other funders. Excerpts from the Earth Negotiations Bulletin may be used in other publications with appropriate citation only. Electronic versions of the Bulletin can be found on the Internet at and in through the Linkages World Wide Web server at . This volume of the Bulletin is uploaded into the APC conferences and . The Earth Negotiations Bulletin may not be reproduced, reprinted or posted to any system or service outside of the APC networks and the ENB listserver, without specific permission from the International Institute for Sustainable Development. This limitation includes distribution via Usenet News, bulletin board systems, mailing lists, print media and broadcast. For more information, send a message to .